QUOTE (mbflyer @ Jun 12 2009, 04:00 AM)

QUOTE (Jacobin777 @ Jun 12 2009, 02:09 AM)

While I love the MadDogs (I think I've flown on every single one of AA's MadDogs in the fleet during the past 12 years..lol), its time for a change. That being said, sitting on the left side of the plane from row 21 on up is quite nice.
It is, but actually I have found that the isle seat on the right (3-seat) side is the most comfortable. The 738s have better amenities, but are not necessarily more comfortable in coach as the seats are at leats 1" narrower. Despite AA puffing about the new seat contour and padding, Southwest has a much more comfortable cabin. In any event, the MDs need to go. Too many reliabilitiy problems that cause delays in ORD and DFW and slow down the AA route system. And with fuel prices going back up, AA would be wise to redeploy some of the 738s on more of its west coast routes out of ORD (particulalry with rumors flying that DL will be repositioning A320s out of MSP and DTW and replacing them with used MD90s). The last AA Fall schedule I saw had several 738s going through LAX, LAS and SEA, but still few assigned to SFO (where AA still has good loads), SAN, and SJC. AA should add ORD-PSP as well. Often very full planes during the winter season in Chicago.
I am flying in seat 20D in a couple of weeks..

I never found AA's cabin to be "uncomfortable". The only time I really found AA "uncomfortable" was when I flew JFK-LHR in J back in April and my seat was busted(needed to be manually adjusted and didn't fully recline)......grrrr.....
That being said, it was a free upgrade (flight was oversold) so I really shouldn't be complaining. Hehe...
Regardless, I agree, the B738's save much more fuel over the MadDogs and their time has indeed come.
Finally, I prefer TW's MadDogs over AAs..